(Photo courtesy of Min Hee-jin's Instagram)


[Hanteo News = Reporter KIM YEONWOO] A first-instance ruling has been issued in the damages lawsuits between former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin and HYBE subsidiaries BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC. The court dismissed both labels' damages claims totaling 2.5 billion won, while also rejecting Min's 5 billion won counterclaim against BELIFT LAB. In response, both BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC expressed disappointment with the ruling and announced plans to file immediate appeals.

On November 13, the 12th Civil Division of the Seoul Western District Court dismissed BELIFT LAB's 2 billion won damages lawsuit and SOURCE MUSIC's 500 million won damages lawsuit against Min. The court also rejected Min's 5 billion won counterclaim against BELIFT LAB and ordered each party to bear its own litigation costs.

 

(Photo courtesy of Min Hee-jin's Instagram)

The legal dispute began in April 2024, when Min raised allegations during press conferences and other public appearances that BELIFT LAB's girl group ILLIT had copied aspects of NewJeans' concept, choreography, and performances.

BELIFT LAB maintained that these allegations were false and had damaged the reputation of both the company and its artists. In June of that year, the label filed a damages lawsuit seeking 2 billion won.

Min subsequently filed a 5 billion won counterclaim, arguing that BELIFT LAB's response had damaged her own reputation.

The lawsuit involving SOURCE MUSIC stemmed from Min's remarks concerning the recruitment and debut preparations of the NewJeans members.

At the time, Min discussed the members' casting process, trainee management, and HYBE's original plans to debut its first girl group.

In particular, she alleged that SOURCE MUSIC had neglected the NewJeans members and that LE SSERAFIM had debuted first despite earlier promises regarding NewJeans' debut.

SOURCE MUSIC disputed her statements, maintaining that they were inaccurate, and filed a 500 million won damages lawsuit in July 2024.

Regarding Min's allegations that ILLIT had copied NewJeans, the court determined that her remarks were primarily subjective assessments and expressions of opinion about similarities between the two groups, rather than statements asserting specific facts.

The court reasoned that criticism and exchanges of opinion concerning similarities between creative works in the popular arts should be broadly protected under freedom of expression.

The court also considered that discussions about similarities between the two groups had already been circulating online before Min publicly raised the allegations.

Even where certain remarks could be interpreted as factual assertions, the court found it difficult to establish unlawfulness, taking into account the public interest surrounding the controversy and the circumstances in which the concerns were raised.

Meanwhile, regarding Min's 5 billion won counterclaim, the court concluded that NewJeans' reputation, public recognition, and ability to attract consumers could not be regarded as achievements resulting solely from Min's individual efforts.

The court also considered the investments and contributions made by ADOR as a corporate entity in establishing the group's success.

In SOURCE MUSIC's lawsuit, the court similarly found that Min's statements concerning the recruitment of NewJeans members, trainee management, and the order in which the groups debuted could not be conclusively characterized as false.

The court reportedly examined the circumstances surrounding changes to the original debut plans, under which NewJeans had initially been expected to debut first before LE SSERAFIM ultimately debuted ahead of them, as well as Min's response at the time.

Regarding her comments about trainee management and treatment, the court also found it difficult to determine that the statements were false, considering the circumstances and accounts provided by those involved.

However, the ruling concerned whether Min bore civil liability for damages arising from her statements. It should be distinguished from a definitive legal determination as to whether ILLIT had actually plagiarized NewJeans.

 

(Photo courtesy of BELIFT LAB)

BELIFT LAB: "A Ruling That Acknowledges Victims but No Perpetrators… We Will Appeal Immediately"

BELIFT LAB expressed strong disappointment with the ruling in an official statement and announced its intention to appeal.

The label stated:

"We deeply regret that the court has issued a ruling that effectively acknowledges the existence of victims but no perpetrators. When the victims and the harmful acts are evident, prematurely granting immunity on the grounds that the statements were merely 'expressions of opinion' or 'rhetorical expressions' will only lead to second and third victims.

"Investigative authorities referred Min Hee-jin's statements to the prosecution with a recommendation for indictment. We submitted the referral decision and requested that the hearings be reopened, but our request was denied. We were not even given an opportunity to have the newly obtained and submitted decisive evidence examined.

"We will immediately file an appeal and seek a ruling from a higher court."

 

(Photo courtesy of SOURCE MUSIC)

SOURCE MUSIC: "We Will Protect Our Artists and Establish the Objective Truth"

SOURCE MUSIC also expressed deep disappointment with the first-instance ruling and announced that it would immediately appeal.

The label stated:

"We express our deep regret over today's first-instance ruling in the lawsuit between our company and Min Hee-jin. Despite the evidence we submitted clearly pointing to the truth, we feel saddened and powerless in the face of a reality in which we have been unable to obtain legal protection.

"Min Hee-jin's reckless false statements have caused substantial damage to a label for which trust with trainees and artists is essential.

"The court sided exclusively with Min Hee-jin and overlooked actions that inflicted irreparable emotional harm on artists who were not even direct parties to the dispute. It also disregarded all the evidence demonstrating Min Hee-jin's malicious intent.

"We will immediately appeal to challenge the unjust first-instance ruling and will continue making every effort to protect our artists and establish the objective truth."

With both BELIFT LAB and SOURCE MUSIC announcing their intentions to appeal, the legal battle between former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin and HYBE's subsidiary labels is expected to continue in a higher court.
 yeonwoo38@hanteo.com